Manchester United’s inconsistent form took another hit as they fell to Brighton in a 2-1 defeat at the Amex Stadium. The Red Devils, coming off a narrow 1-0 win against Fulham, were expected to build momentum, but Erik ten Hag’s decision to stick with the same starting lineup raised eyebrows among fans and pundits alike.
Brighton capitalized on a mistake by United’s defense in the 32nd minute. Harry Maguire failed to clear a dangerous ball, allowing Kaoru Mitoma to pounce and set up former Manchester United player Danny Welbeck for an easy tap-in. It was a bitter blow for United, and things almost got worse when Welbeck’s header from a set-piece struck the crossbar shortly after.
United struggled to find rhythm, and it wasn’t until the 60th minute that they managed to equalize. A brilliant through ball from Noussair Mazraoui found Amad Diallo, who cut inside and saw his shot deflect off a Brighton defender, leaving the goalkeeper with no chance.
The Red Devils thought they had completed the turnaround when Alejandro Garnacho slotted home from a Bruno Fernandes cross following a swift counter-attack. However, the joy was short-lived, as VAR ruled the goal out for offside after the ball struck Joshua Zirkzee before crossing the line.
In a dramatic finish, Brighton delivered the final blow in the 95th minute. Simon Adingra’s pinpoint cross found Joao Pedro, who rose above United’s defense to head home the winner. It was a moment that summed up United’s day—a lack of composure and focus at crucial moments.
Criticism of Ten Hag’s tactics has been vocal, particularly his decision to play Bruno Fernandes as a false nine. Fernandes, known for his creativity and playmaking abilities, struggled to influence the game from this unfamiliar role. Fans were left questioning why a natural striker like Zirkzee was not given the nod to start, providing United with the focal point they desperately needed.
Overall, Manchester United’s performance was lackluster. They lacked urgency, even when behind, and failed to capitalize on the few opportunities they created. As the pressure mounts on Ten Hag, questions will be asked about his tactical decisions and whether this squad can consistently challenge the league’s top teams.
